What is the meaning of the equal sign?

At the close of last year, I was working with my fifth grade students on equivalence. I gave them the following question after seeing something similar in an NCTM monthly article:

4+7=\square

\square=3+4

4+23=\square+6=\square

My hope with this question was to understand how my students interpreted the equal sign. As I had guessed, they had two understandings equality and “the answer.” In 5th grade, I expected these two responses and we worked together to clarify the meaning.

As this school year began, I was curious how my 12th grade Calculus students would answer the same question. I gave my seniors the same prompt and I got one of two responses below.

equalsign

It was extremely interesting to me that both 5th graders and 12th graders had the same misunderstanding. It made me think about how many other mathematical misunderstandings students acquire through grade school without being corrected and as teachers what are we doing to help prevent these subtle, but critical misunderstandings.

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “What is the meaning of the equal sign?

  1. For my chemistry students, there’s always a few I have to fight regarding equals signs versus arrows when writing chemical equations. The two sides of chemical equations are NOT equal, it’s a process!

    Is there just some sort of comfort in using equals signs, since they’ve been in math for their entire school career?

    Like

  2. I’m always fascinated by the way technology sometimes reinforces misunderstanding. For example, the “4 + 23 = 27 + 6 = 33” misunderstanding makes perfect sense if the student uses a calculator that behaves that way.

    Like

  3. While all the suggestions above are interesting, I really think this is explicitly about what exposure kids have. Much of what we teach is geared toward teaching kids the process of adding, or the process of mutliplying, etc, etc. If we have more opportunities to talk about equivalent expressions, and not just teaching kids how to compute, then they’d have real exposure to equations with multiple terms on the left and one on the right (3+4=7), or multiple terms on both sides (3+4=2+5), or even multiple equal signs (7=1+6=2+5).

    Where are there opportunities to discuss equivalence in your curriculum? We should tag them with a post-it to remind us to strike while the iron’s hot…

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s